Card #461 · Prolific Marketplace
Vague and repetitive app review rejections
Developers are experiencing frustration with a review process that provides generic rejection messages without specifying which test cases or tool calls failed. Many report that their apps pass all tests locally on both web and mobile, but they continue to receive the same non-specific feedback from reviewers.
Pain score
0.19/ 1.00 · weighted product of four components
Reach0.57distinct authors (log-normalized)
Recency1.00freshness decay, half-life months
Engagement0.78upvotes + comments, normalized
Monetization0.50willingness-to-pay cues in evidence
§ Evidence — 3 verified quotes
It’s extremely discouraging to get e-mails with “general” rejections which leave us guessing as to what OpenAI is actually rejecting.
I’ve thoroughly re-tested everything on my side, and all test cases return the expected results.
My application has been rejected 3 times during the review process, and each time I received the same message: “One or more of your test cases did not produce correct results.
Comments are a Pro feature — join the conversation, share what you've shipped, hear what others are building.
Upgrade to Pro